SHIP STABILITY, THEORY AND PRACTICE · VOLUME TWO · APPLIED STABILITY AND TRIM

Chapter 7 · The Trim Engine: LCG, LCB and Final Draughts

The complete workflow: read the ship’s LCG from her draughts, run the grand moments table, and land the final draughts to the centimetre.

Chapter 6 built the parts: the pivot at F, MCTC the exchange rate, the TMD, the sharing rule. This chapter bolts them into the engine that answers the question every loading plan ends with: after all this cargo, what will her draughts be? The method is the longitudinal twin of the KG moments table of Volume One: weights times levers, this time measured from the after perpendicular, meeting the booklet twice, once on the way in and once on the way out.

7.1 What makes a trim: the couple

A floating ship carries her weight down through G and her buoyancy up through B. If LCG and LCB stand on the same vertical, she floats at rest; if not, the pair form a couple that rotates her about F until the shifting underwater volume brings B back beneath G. The trim she takes up to achieve this is priced by the booklet:

Trim (cm) = Δ × (LCB − LCG) ÷ MCTCpositive by the stern; LCB and LCG measured forward of the after perpendicular

The bracket LCB − LCG is the trimming lever and its sign gives the direction: positive when G is abaft B, and then the trim is by the stern; negative when G is forward of B, and then the trim is by the head. The deep end is always the end G is closer to. Trim by the stern is positive throughout, so a trim of −25 cm is 25 cm by the head.

G (LCG 76.765)weight downbuoyancy upB (LCB 77.032)the lever: LCB − LCGWhat makes a trim: the couple between weight and buoyancyB forward of G: the stern drops until the shifting underwater volume brings B back beneath GTrim (cm) = Δ × (LCB − LCG) ÷ MCTCpositive, by the stern, when G is abaft B;negative, by the head, when G is forward of BThe condition drawn is Worked example 7.3 on completion: the 0.267 m lever gives 19.6 cm of stern trim (separation exaggerated).
Figure 7.1   Weight down through G, buoyancy up through B: the lever between them, times the displacement and divided by MCTC, is the trim.

7.2 The engine, in seven steps

Every full trim problem in the examination room runs the same seven steps, and the discipline is worth more than any single formula: the booklet is consulted twice, at the floating condition and again at the final displacement, because Δ, LCB, LCF and MCTC all drift as she sinks.

The trim engine: seven steps, no shortcutsthe course procedure, run left to right through every full trim problem1Draughts to TMDtrim from the perpendiculars; TMD = aft draught ± trim × LCF ÷ LBP2TMD into the tablesinterpolate the row: Δ, LCB, LCF, MCTC at the floating condition3Read the ship’s LCGLCG = LCB ± (trim in cm × MCTC) ÷ Δ: subtract for stern trim4Grand moments about APload and discharge every parcel: new Δ and new LCG5New Δ into the tablesinterpolate the final row: TMD, LCB, LCF, MCTC all move6Final trimtrim = Δ × (LCB − LCG) ÷ MCTC: by the stern if positive7Final draughtsaft = TMD + trim × LCF ÷ LBP; forward = aft − trim
Figure 7.2   The course procedure. Steps 2 and 5 are the two visits to the booklet; everything between them is arithmetic.

7.3 Steps 1 to 3: reading the LCG from the draughts

Worked example 7.1

MV Ninja lies at draughts 8.10 m forward, 8.90 m aft. Find her displacement and LCG (booklet rows: 8.40 m: Δ 26242 t, MCTC 391.9, LCB 77.65, LCF 72.46, TPC 34.80; 8.60 m: Δ 26941 t, MCTC 394.5, LCB 77.51, LCF 72.32, TPC 34.92; LBP 148 m).

Trim = 8.90 − 8.10 = 0.80 m by the stern. First pass LCF at the 8.50 m mean: 72.39 m; TMD = 8.90 − (0.80 × 72.39 ÷ 148) = 8.509 m.

Interpolate at 8.509 m (8.5087 m before rounding), fraction 0.544 up the interval: Δ 26622 t, MCTC 393.3 t m, LCB 77.574 m, LCF 72.384 m, TPC 34.87.

LCB − LCG = trim (cm) × MCTC ÷ Δ = 80 × 393.3 ÷ 26622 = 1.182 m.

Stern trim means LCG stands abaft of LCB: LCG = 77.574 − 1.182 = 76.392 m foap (76.39 m). Two draught readings and the booklet have given both the displacement and the position of the centre of gravity.

LCB 77.574LCG 76.392APFPThe reverse problem: reading the LCG from the draughtsdraughts 8.10 and 8.90 give TMD 8.509 m; the interpolated row and the trim formula do the restLCB − LCG = trim (cm) × MCTC ÷ Δ = 80 × 393.3 ÷ 26622 = 1.182 mstern trim, so LCG stands abaft of LCB: 77.574 − 1.182 = 76.392 m foap
Figure 7.3   The reverse problem of Worked example 7.1: from draughts to TMD to the interpolated row to LCG.
Laboratory 1 · The LCG reader: from two draughts to displacement and LCG
The laboratory runs steps 1 to 3 live: TMD (with the LCF it implies), the interpolated row, and the LCG. Set the sliders to 8.10 and 8.90 to reproduce Worked example 7.1 exactly.

7.4 Step 4: the grand moments table about the after perpendicular

Worked example 7.2

From the condition of Worked example 7.1 the following is worked: load 2000 t in No. 2 hold (lcg 105.09 m foap) and 1500 t in No. 4 hold (56.55 m); discharge 800 t from No. 3 hold (80.82 m); take 300 t of heavy fuel oil, RD 0.950, into the No. 2 HFO tanks port and starboard (32.91 m). Find the final displacement and LCG. (Compartment positions are the booklet's.)

Capacity check on the bunkers first: 300 ÷ 0.950 = 315.8 m³ against 2 × 174.8 = 349.6 m³ in the pair of tanks, so the oil fits.

ItemWeight (t)lcg (m foap)Moment (t m)
Ship as floating2662276.3922033708
Load No. 2 hold+2000105.09+210180
Load No. 4 hold+150056.55+84825
Discharge No. 3 hold−80080.82−64656
Bunkers, No. 2 HFO tanks P and S+30032.91+9873
Totals2962276.7652273930

Final LCG = 2273930 ÷ 29622 = 76.765 m foap. The table is the KG table of Volume One rotated ninety degrees: same discipline, levers now measured from the after perpendicular, discharges subtracting weight and moment alike.

+2000 tNo.2 hold: 105.09 foap+1500 tNo.4 hold: 56.55 foap−800 tNo.3 hold: 80.82 foap+300 t HFONo.2 HFO tanks: 32.91 foapAP: the datum for every leverThe grand moments table, drawn: every parcel times its lever foaploads add weight and moment, discharges subtract both; the totals hand over Δ and LCG in one divisionfinal LCG = final moment ÷ final displacement= 2273930 ÷ 29622 = 76.765 m foap
Figure 7.4   The grand table drawn on the ship: every parcel times its lever foap, all referred to the AP datum.

7.5 Steps 5 to 7: the second visit to the booklet, and the answer

Worked example 7.3

Complete the problem: find MV Ninja’s final draughts (booklet rows: 9.20 m: Δ 29046 t, MCTC 401.4, LCB 77.13, LCF 72.00; 9.40 m: Δ 29751 t, MCTC 403.6, LCB 77.01, LCF 71.91).

Enter with Δ = 29622 t: fraction (29622 − 29046) ÷ 705 = 0.817 up the interval, so TMD 9.363 m, MCTC 403.2 t m, LCB 77.032 m, LCF 71.926 m: every constant differs from the value read in Worked example 7.1, which is exactly why the booklet is consulted twice.

Final trim = Δ × (LCB − LCG) ÷ MCTC = 29622 × (77.032 − 76.765) ÷ 403.2 = 29622 × 0.267 ÷ 403.2 = 19.6 cm by the stern (positive: G abaft B).

Draught aft = TMD + trim × LCF ÷ LBP = 9.363 + 0.196 × 71.926 ÷ 148 = 9.363 + 0.095 = 9.458 m (9.46 m).

Draught forward = 9.458 − 0.196 = 9.262 m (9.26 m). Check: the pair give trim 0.196 m and TMD 9.458 − (0.196 × 71.926 ÷ 148) = 9.363 m: the draughts return the TMD they were built from. Had the initial constants (LCB 77.574, MCTC 393.3) been kept, the lever would have read 0.809 m and the trim 60.9 cm, three times the true figure.

Assembling the final draughts: TMD first, trim shared secondthe TMD anchors the draught at F; the 19.6 cm of stern trim is then shared out by the leversTMD at F (from the final row)9.363 maft share: + 19.6 × 71.926 ÷ 148+ 0.095 mdraught aft9.458 mless the whole trim− 0.196 mdraught forward9.262 m
Figure 7.5   Assembling the answer: the TMD anchors the draught at F, then the 19.6 cm is shared by the levers.
Why step 5 exists: the tables drift as she sinksbetween the initial and final conditions of Worked example 7.3, every constant movedinitial (TMD 8.509)final (TMD 9.363)driftΔ (t)2662229622+3000MCTC (t m)393.3403.2+9.9LCB (m foap)77.57477.032−0.542LCF (m foap)72.38471.926−0.458hold the constants across 3000 t and the trim reads 60.9 cm instead of 19.6 cm:re enter the tables with the final displacement, always
Figure 7.6   Between the two visits every constant moved: hold them fixed across 3000 t and the trim comes out three times too large.
Laboratory 2 · The trim engine: edit the cargo plan and find the final draughts
base condition: draughts 8.10 / 8.90 (Δ 26622 t, LCG 76.392 foap), as Worked example 7.1; default parcel positions are the booklet's hold and tank centres
Four editable parcels (negative weight = discharge). The engine reruns steps 4 to 7 on every keystroke, interpolating the booklet at the final displacement. The defaults reproduce Worked examples 7.2 and 7.3 to the centimetre.

7.6 Placing a parcel to order

Worked example 7.4

A final 500 t parcel remains. The master wants MV Ninja to sail on an even keel. Where must it be stowed (booklet row 9.60 m: Δ 30456 t, MCTC 405.7, LCB 76.90 m)?

Even keel demands final LCG = final LCB. At Δ = 29622 + 500 = 30122 t, fraction (30122 − 29751) ÷ 705 = 0.526 between the 9.40 and 9.60 rows: LCB = 76.952 m foap, MCTC 404.7.

Taking moments: required lcg = (76.952 × 30122 − 2273930) ÷ 500 = (2317948 − 2273930) ÷ 500 = 44018 ÷ 500 = 88.0 m foap: 7.2 m forward of the centre of No. 3 hold (80.82 m), so in the forward part of No. 3.

A check on the size of the task: the LCG has to move only 0.187 m forward (from 76.765 to 76.952 m), and 500 t does that from a lever of about 11 m. Stowed right at the forward perpendicular the same parcel would give 74.1 cm of trim by the head, and at the after perpendicular 108.7 cm by the stern; nothing beyond those limits is available from 500 t. Had the answer fallen outside the hull, the demand could not be met with 500 t, and the options would be a heavier parcel nearer amidships or a ballast transfer: the same moments, written differently.

Laboratory 3 · The parcel placer: choose the final trim, find the stowage
Starting from the completed condition of Worked example 7.3 (Δ 29622 t, LCG 76.765 m foap). Positive trim is by the stern. The feasibility chip turns red when the required stowage falls outside the hull: a small parcel cannot buy a big change of trim.

7.7 Two roads, one ship: verifying the engine

Worked example 7.5

From the Worked example 7.1 condition, a single 300 t parcel is loaded into No. 5 hold, lcg 32.86 m foap. Find the final draughts twice: once by the small tool of Chapter 6 (sinkage plus moment about F, constants held), and once by the full engine (constants re read). Compare.

Route A. Sinkage = 300 ÷ 34.87 = 8.6 cm. Arm from F = 72.384 − 32.86 = 39.52 m abaft; CoT = 300 × 39.52 ÷ 393.3 = 30.1 cm by the stern, shared 14.7 cm aft, 15.4 cm forward. Final: F 8.10 + 0.086 − 0.154 = 8.032 m; A 8.90 + 0.086 + 0.147 = 9.133 m.

Route B. New Δ = 26922 t, new LCG = (2033708 + 300 × 32.86) ÷ 26922 = 2043566 ÷ 26922 = 75.907 m; re entering the tables at fraction 0.973: TMD 8.595 m, MCTC 394.4, LCB 77.514 m, LCF 72.324 m; lever 1.607 m and the trim formula gives 26922 × 1.607 ÷ 394.4 = 109.7 cm by the stern. Final: A 8.595 + 1.097 × 72.324 ÷ 148 = 9.131 m, F 9.131 − 1.097 = 8.034 m.

Agreement: 2 mm at each end, less than a draught mark can be read to. For one small parcel the Chapter 6 tool is quick and adequate; for a full cargo plan only the engine, with its second visit to the booklet, gives the correct answer.

Two roads, one ship: the small tool against the full engine300 t loaded into No. 5 hold, 39.52 m abaft of F, worked both ways from the Worked example 7.1 conditionRoute A: sinkage + moment about FF 8.032 m · A 9.133 mconstants heldRoute B: the full LCG engineF 8.034 m · A 9.131 mconstants re readagreement: 2 mm at each endfor one small parcel the two routes agree within a few millimetres;for a full cargo plan only the engine gives the correct answer
Figure 7.7   The dual verification of Worked example 7.5: two independent routes land within millimetres.

Chapter 7 in five lines

Trim is caused by a couple: Trim (cm) = Δ × (LCB − LCG) ÷ MCTC, positive and by the stern when G is abaft B.

The floating ship gives her LCG: TMD into the tables, then LCG = LCB − trim × MCTC ÷ Δ for stern trim.

The grand table is the KG table turned lengthways: weights times levers foap, discharges negative, one division at the end.

Visit the booklet twice: Δ, LCB, LCF and MCTC all drift with draught, and the final row is the one that prices the answer.

Finish at F: draught aft = TMD + trim × LCF ÷ LBP, forward = aft − trim, and the answer must loop back to its own TMD.

Test yourself